Photo Gallery 12 Images
CRESWELL, Ore. – A Creswell woman sentenced in a massive horse neglect case more than a year ago will soon be back in court over claims she violated her probation.
Gwenyth Davies, 50, was required to follow specific conditions and pay restitution of nearly $50,000 in monthly increments in order to avoid jail time. She pleaded guilty to 11 counts of second-degree animal neglect in early 2020.
A total of 61 horses were removed from her property in October 2019 as part of the investigation. Authorities said a veterinarian found that the horses were not receiving the minimum care standards under Oregon law.
Now, court documents show Davies has failed to pay restitution and to provide monthly pictures of the four horses she’s allowed to have so authorities can ensure their body condition is healthy.
Lane County Circuit Court Judge Charles Zennache has ordered Davies to appear in court and show why her probation should not be revoked and a jail sentence imposed.
The court hearing is scheduled for April 26 at 8:30 a.m.
The $49,557.36 in restitution was set to be directed to the following groups at the time of Davies' sentencing:
- $18,540.07 to the Oregon Humane Society
- $10,637.90 to Lane County
- $20,379.39 to Sound Equine Options
According to the payment plan that has been agreed upon, Davies was supposed to pay $300 a month toward restitution.
Under probation, Davies is also not allowed to board other horses.
Special prosecutor Jacob Kamins said at the time of the sentencing that Davies accepted responsibility.
"This would not be a case I would enter into negotiations with unless there was some showing of early acceptance of responsibility on Mrs. Davies' part," Kamins said.
The Lane County Sheriff's Office said the plea agreement allowed the state to place restrictions on Davies' horse ownership that may not have been possible if the case had gone to trial.
“One of main goals in this case was to ensure this type of neglect doesn’t occur again, and this agreement allows for a level of oversight that can aid in achieving that goal,” said Sheriff Cliff Harrold.
The sheriff's office said that during the investigation, four dead horses were found at the property. During the seizure, horses were evaluated by a veterinarian and taken to another location for care. Three horses did not survive, the sheriff's office said.
Davies' attorney Laura Fine told the judge that Davies worked with the sheriff's office to help reunite owners with their animals.
"She reviewed photos of all seized horses, provided owner information and specific details about the horses' conditions and needs," Fine said.
Most of the remaining horses were returned to their owners. At the time of the sentencing, four were still being held pending criminal charges against their owners, Erica and Raina Ott, who lived on the same property as Davies. They have been charged and convicted with second-degree animal neglect in connection with the Davies case.
Davies has had previous contacts with Lane County Animal Services in 2018 regarding horses in poor condition, authorities said.
She lives at the property with her husband Michael DeLeonardo. In 2018, Davies complied with Lane County Animal Services’ requests and the horses were brought to minimum standards. The current investigation began on Oct. 16, 2019, and evidence suggested that the abuses may be criminal.
"Certainly looking at the emaciated horses it's clear to even people who aren't around horses a lot that's not what a horse should look like. It's important that we let the investigation continue and let the Oregon Humane Society gather evidence," said Lane County spokesperson Devon Ashbridge.
It started when Lane County Animal Services received photographs of horses that appeared to be severely neglected. The photographs were provided by Emerald Valley Equine Rescue after it received multiple complaints from people who once boarded their horses with Davies.
Neighbors KEZI 9 News spoke to recount seeing a back field on the property filled with horses, some showing ribs and hips. They also recounted hearing gunshots on the property regularly.
High-schooler Breonah Jones trains her own horses on an adjacent property. She describes rarely seeing the horses fed.
"They should have had food back there, 100%; they had so many horses in that back field that there wasn't even any grass. Just sheer dirt," she said. "They should be put into jail for a very long time for each and every horse that they did that to."
However, Carol Mingst, the owner of three horses taken from Davies' property, said the Lane County Sheriff's office went too far and her horses were not neglected.
"He is lightweight because he has a broken bone in his leg," Mingst said, referring to one of her horses. "He can't have a lot of weight on it. He's also slimmed down because he lost a lot of weight when he was sick."
Due to the large number of involved horses, Lane County reached out to the Oregon Humane Society and rescue organizations to begin identifying people who could help with the evaluation, removal, treatment and housing of so many large animals – which far exceeds local capacity.
The Lane County District Attorney’s Office is working with Oregon Animal Cruelty Deputy District Attorney Jake Kamins, who specializes in the prosecution of animal cruelty cases.
“Ms. Davies is known to Animal Services,” said Bernard Perkins, Lane County senior animal welfare officer. “While we typically focus on voluntary compliance and education, the level of alleged neglect and Ms. Davies’ history of violations goes far beyond what is acceptable in our community. We are grateful for the support of the sheriff’s office and district attorney in the pursuit of criminal charges.”
Sound Equine Options, Emerald Valley Horse Rescue, Oregon Humane Society, and Lane County Land Management Division all assisted with the rescue operation and property compliance issues.